Who Put All These "Shoulds" on My List?

Letting Go of the Shoulds
This past Monday morning at 6:30am, I woke up already annoyed with myself. The Wednesday before, I'd started putting together a pretty ambitious list of things I wanted to accomplish over the weekend. Clean the garage. Fix the molding around the bedroom floor. Do laundry. Figure out why one of the ceiling fans had abruptly stopped working (not cool... like, literally not cool). I'd convinced myself that if I knocked it all out on Saturday, I could spend Sunday watching football relatively guilt-free (sorry, wife... only 14 weekends left). Seemed like a reasonable plan. Except Monday rolled around, the list was still mostly a list, and instead of thinking about what I had done or how I'd enjoyed my weekend, I was beating myself up over everything I hadn't.
And it got me thinking...
How many other people do that to themselves? Serious question, how many things do you have sitting in the back of your mind right now that you keep telling yourself you should be doing?
You should lose weight. You should organize that closet. You should exercise more, put the Christmas lights up on the house before it gets too cold (okay, personal one), clean out your vehicle. Or maybe it’s something big and emotional and you just can’t seem to figure out where to begin. Your inside voice (known for causing problems for many of us) is telling you that you should have figured it out by now. You should be further along. You should care more.
And every day you don't do those things, that pesky inside voice keeps reminding you that you're falling short.
But what if you just... stopped?
What if you made a conscious decision to let go of some of those shoulds? Not because you're lazy, irresponsible, or giving up, but because you're tired of carrying around an imaginary list of obligations that makes you feel like you're never quite enough when you don’t check them off the list.
There is a huge problem with constantly telling ourselves what we should be doing and that is, over time, it changes how we see ourselves. Ever hear the saying, “The mind is everything. What you think, you become?" When we start measuring our worth against unfinished tasks, unmet expectations, and arbitrary deadlines that do nothing but stress us out, we start creating a story about ourselves and the plot is always that we are failing at adulthood, as if everyone else got an instruction manual for life and ours is sitting somewhere in the garage we still haven't cleaned. We convince ourselves that until we lose the weight, clean the house, fix the relationship, or accomplish that next big thing, we're somehow failing. That we're less deserving of love, happiness, or success.
And my goodness, that's a pretty exhausting way to live!
And just to be clear, I'm not suggesting we all abandon our responsibilities and start treating basic adulting like an optional extracurricular activity. Trust me, the mortgage company won’t accept "I just wasn't feeling it" as a valid excuse. There's a difference between procrastinating on something that genuinely needs to get done and beating yourself up over something you've simply decided you should do. One is avoiding responsibility. The other is creating an obligation that may not have needed to exist in the first place. But so many of the things we beat ourselves up about aren't actual obligations. They're weird expectations we've absorbed from other people, society, social media, or some fairytale Type A version of who we think we're supposed to be. Sorry Type A folks, we love you, but man, you set the bar pretty high for the rest of us.
What if, instead of mentally tormenting yourself about what you should do, you started asking yourself what you actually want to do?
What matters to you right now? What feels healthy, meaningful, enjoyable, or even just relaxing? What would it feel like to make those choices without guilt tagging along?
My wife is so much better at resting than I am. She's always reminding me, "You don't have to be doing anything right now." I wish I believed her! And while I've gotten much better at the actual doing nothing part, I'm still working on the not feeling guilty about it part. Apparently, sitting still and giving myself permission to sit are two very different skills.
But I'm learning there's a difference between putting something off because I'm avoiding it and choosing to put it off because something else matters more to me in that moment (like that fun video game that my wife and I play). And maybe that's where we need to give ourselves a little more grace. Rest doesn't have to be earned, and every unfinished task doesn't need to come with a side of guilt.
Maybe you'll organize that closet next month. Maybe you'll work on your health when you're ready to approach it from a place of self-care rather than self-criticism. I personally decided to take care of my health in that way. I love to exercise, but making it a thing that I had to do because if not I am a terrible person, made it unbearable. I will work out again, it’s just not today. And probably not tomorrow, but I will. Maybe you'll decide that making peace with someone who hurt you isn't something you owe anyone.
Some of those shoulds might eventually become things you genuinely want to do. Others might never make the cut. And that's okay. You get to decide what deserves your time and energy, and when, without turning everything you haven't done into a reason to feel bad about yourself.
Because the point isn't to give up on the things that matter. It's to stop punishing yourself for not doing everything, all the time, on some imaginary schedule.
Give Yourself Permission
You can give yourself permission to do things when they're right for you, on a timeline that makes sense for your life—not some imaginary deadline you've been using to judge yourself.
Letting go of the shoulds isn't about giving up on yourself. It's about letting go of the idea that you have to constantly improve, accomplish, fix, or produce something to be worthy.
You are allowed to enjoy your life while it's still a work in progress.
You are allowed to rest without earning it, change your mind without explaining it, and leave some things undone without turning them into a reflection of your character.
Your Shoulds Are Not the Boss of You
If you're ready to lighten that mental load, try this little exercise:
Get the shoulds out of your head. Write down everything you've been telling yourself you should do. Big things, little things, all of it. No judgment.
Ask whose expectation it really is. Is this something you genuinely want or need to do? Or is it something you think you're supposed to do because of someone else's expectations, societal pressure, or an outdated idea of who you should be?
Separate responsibilities from optional expectations. Some things truly need your attention. Others can wait, change, or disappear from the list entirely. Give yourself permission to decide which ones fall into which categories for you.
Replace "I should" with "I choose." Instead of "I should clean out that closet," try "I may choose to clean out that closet when I have the time and energy." Notice how different that feels.
Let go of the imaginary deadline. Unless there's a real consequence attached to a date, you don't need one. You can revisit something next week, next year, or decide it no longer matters.
Practice letting yourself off the hook. When that familiar guilt creeps in, remind yourself: I'm not failing because I'm choosing something else right now.
The goal isn't to create yet another self-improvement assignment. It's to take some of the pressure off. You don't even have to do this exercise perfectly—or at all. Meh... who cares?
Taking the Next Step
If your list of shoulds has started to feel heavier than your life, you don’t have to sort through it alone. At Manifest Joy Counseling, we help people in Tucson quiet the inner critic, let go of guilt, and figure out what actually matters to them, at a pace that works for their life.
Ready to lighten the mental load? Contact Manifest Joy Counseling at 520.885.1033 or manifestjoycounseling.com to schedule a free 15-minute consultation.






Comments